Sorry, marijuana will not likely be legal in Canada on April 20, 2017

Either through new legislation or an amendment to the CDSA, the process of creating a new regime for legal marijuana in Canada will likely take some time

Canada’s formal announcement of its intention to legalize cannabis at a UN meeting earlier this year grabbed headlines around the world. As Canada is the first G20 nation to take on this task at the federal level, the excitement is understandable.

Canada's Health Minister, Jane Philpott made the announcement on April 20th of this year, at the UN General Assembly’s Special Session (UNGASS) on Drugs in Washington DC., saying the government intends to introduce a Bill in the spring of 2017 to regulate and control access to cannabis.

"We will introduce legislation in spring 2017 that ensures we keep marijuana out of the hands of children and profits out of the hands of criminals," Minister Philpott told the UN audience.

Since the time of that announcement, rumours have swirled about just exactly what this means. Some believed cannabis was legal the moment the Liberals won the election in October, 2015. Articles declaring April 20, 2017 as the day it will be legalized had a great deal of traction, likely because it makes a great story. The real story is a bit more complicated.

What the Liberal government has done is promise to introduce legislation to Parliament in the Spring of 2017 that will seek to “control and regulate” marijuana. This process is expected to work its way through the Canadian Parliamentary system over several months, with many predicting ‘full legalization’ not being functional in Canada until early 2018, or later.

The government announced a task force earlier this year to gather input from across the country, which will help guide the expected legislation. The task force is expected to give their results later this month. Their findings are expected to be made public in the future, as well.

These findings are expected to inform the legislation that the government has said they will introduce in the Spring of 2017. Short of changing tact and proposing an amendment to the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act (CDSA), which is to date how medical cannabis has been managed in Canada, this is the expected course of action.

So what is going on in Canada with legalization? Two possible paths

First, it’s important to understand the difference between legislation and legalization. What the Liberal government has promised to do is introduce legislation in the Spring of 2017. This can mean any time between late March and mid to late June when Parliament takes a summer break until mid September.

This bill would have to take the normal path of any new legislation in Canada, passing through the House and Senate, three readings, and debate, before Royal Assent which can take several months or more. If the Liberals introduce something in the early Spring, it could be debated and passed before the Summer break, but it’s also possible that the debate will continue on into the Fall or even Winter session.

Some industry experts have predicted no functional legislation until early 2018, but the Liberals have already drafted, debated, and passed nine pieces of legislation during the first 12 weeks of sitting in 2016.

In an interview with Lift earlier this year, Shane Morris, VP of Quality Assurance and Scientific Affairs at Hydropothecary, a medical cannabis producer in Quebec, and a former executive in the Canadian federal government, says he believes Canada is a year, possibly even more away from “full legalization”.

“The Bill will take several months under debate in the House and Senate, plus new regulatory elements will have to be designed and consulted on,” said Morris. “As a result, we are well over a year, perhaps even two or more, from having a system up and running for full legalization.”

While this unfolds, the provinces, territories and municipalities are also working to come up with rules and guidelines to adhere to this new legislation, which itself could take a considerable amount of time. Concerns with where production facilities are located have already been an issue with Canada’s medical cannabis program, and local and provincial governments are already struggling with how to manage eager entrepreneurs seeking to stake a claim in the retail dispensary space.

Will cities be able to ban retail sales or commercial or even personal production? Will provinces have control over sales and distribution of cannabis similar to how they currently manage alcohol? Will Provinces set legal age limits? All of this remains to be understood and debated at the provincial, territorial and municipal levels.

Adding together these layers of government and competing interests and jurisdictions, it’s easy to see how this could drag on through 2017 and into 2018, possibly even longer.

However, Hugo Alves, a corporate and commercial lawyer and advisor in the medical marijuana industry in Canada, says another possible path the government could take to speed up this process is to propose an amendment to the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act. Alves is a Partner at Bennett Jones, LLC, counsel to the Cannabis Canada Association and the Canadians for Fair Access to Medical Marijuana. Bennett Jones is also an advisor to Canopy Growth Corporation.

While this isn’t the language used by Minister Philpott, it’s a similar approach to how the government has managed access to medical cannabis in the past. Canada has provided access to medical marijuana via Section 56 exemptions to the CDSA since 1999, through three different medical access programs (MMAR, MMPR, ACMPR).

This could still take several months, as well says Alves, but he believes it’s a very real possibility.

“It’s not like the use of cannabis is completely foreign to Canadians,” says Alves. “You’re really just expanding the class of people that can access cannabis, legally. First, you have to step back and ask: ‘What is the government going to do, are they going to introduce a new Act of Parliament, or are they going to pass regulations under an existing act?’”

Alves points out that much of the framework the government can rely on for things like production have already been created through existing medical legislation. What is left is more about expanding who can access that existing supply chain, although he also allows that there could also be new rules for new ‘artisan’ or craft growers not currently regulated through the ACMPR/MMPR.

“If you want to go back to even the MMAR, that was a radical change. (The government) was making a substance that was previously prohibited, accessible to medical users. So I think that’s the closest analogy. Here it’s a continuation of that. You’re making a substance that was previously prohibited for a certain subset of people now legally permissible. In some ways, this is a lesser exercise than the MMAR or the MMPR was, in that you’re not creating all the regulations around the production of cannabis, this is more of a kind of consumption regulations.

“We don’t know, yet, we don’t have a sense of how broad ranging these rules are going to be. Whether they’re going to include, for example, different categories of growers. Could there be an accommodation for the smaller, artisanal grower that’s not subject to the full blown regulations of the ACMPR? Maybe. I don’t really know, although it wouldn't entirely surprise me.

“Fast would be something like 10 weeks. You can pass regs in as quick as 48 hours, but I don’t see that happening. But if you look at the most analogous experience, of the MMPR, it was published in Part 1 of the Gazette on December 15, 2012 and then it was registered, i.e. became law, on June 7 2013, so approximately six months. That wouldn’t be an unreasonable period of time, given what we know about the level of submissions to the task force, international treaty implications for Canada, etc. So with these issues, it could be somewhere in that six month period.”

Either of these paths mean it's not likely any adults in Canada will be buying marijuana legally any time soon, and maybe not until 2018. In the meantime, consumers will have to wait patiently or continue to use the flourishing online and bricks and mortar dispensaries, many of whom are increasingly eschewing any medical thresholds,  to get their cannabis.

Featured image via Davechan.ca

The Dispensary Vancouver adult use

In this article

Join the Conversation

9 comments

  1. William Bedivere Reply

    When will this insanity end? In the meantime there needs to be a moratorium on arresting cannabis users, and this includes those selling via dispensaries. Cannabis is not as harmful as prohibition, the only people saying the opposite are suffering from a mental illness called reefer madness.

  2. Grant Reply

    Are the Liberals going to continue their 'bait and switch' routines? Prolonging decriminalization steps is cruel and heartless. What is this I hear about a clogged criminal justice system and overworked and underfunded prosecutors and public defenders? Stays of prosecution? Sounds like there is enough to do without victimizing peaceful people over a plant. Focus the Justice System on actual, not perceived harms (based on unsubstantiated fears & propagandist rhetoric). This is how you root out the 'criminal element'. Deal with the actual violence, fraud and theft irrespective of, what should be, a legal, self-regulated commodity.

  3. Patrick Smyth Reply

    Well written Dave.

  4. SkyPilot Reply

    As I call it: The Great Canadian Cannabis Decriminalization Stall Date

    Here's an idea: work cannabis into the primary school curriculum, we do it with other things that we think kids should be aware or afraid of.

    One thing I suggest: When you see all the anti-drinking warnings aimed at youth, then tend to go right up to the last years of high school then a complete about face once they're in University. It's like a switch is flipped with a lit sign that say's drink..drink like we show you in the commercials.

  5. Maxcatski Reply

    Keep your medical authorization in effect if you want to obtain legal cannabis any time in the near future. Once the new regulations are passed and in effect, it will still take up to six months to bring on any new source of supply for the recreational market. Growing your own under the ACMPR is currently the only way to ensure you will have access to the strains you need. Peace, Maxcatski

  6. Jack Bloombang Reply

    I will be very surprised if Canada legalizes nationally within 4 years. Trudeau is the Obama of Canada and, even though people gave him the nod for PM, it still doesn't mean he is in control of the country by any means. The MJ reform rhetoric is a pipe dream at best. Sure, legislation will likely be introduced but its passage would still be nothing short of a miracle.

  7. Owen Reply

    So we wanted legal weed and ended up with the worst form of government in Canadian history and they mislead us on when it would be legal, there's nothing like being mislead on legal dope and then being taxed a million or two so your government can have limosine rides and renovated accommodations plus luxurious trips to god knows where

    1. Profile photo of David Brown

      David Brown Reply

      No one was mislead. The government was very clear about their intentions.

  8. Northspecter Reply

    If there is any bs with this bill to pass, I will be furious, for 3 reasons....

    1--------It was the backbone of your election platform.
    2--------It is absolutely essential that pot be legal
    3--------big tax cow for government